Has the 2016 Election Chaos Spoiled the ‘Spoiler’ Theory of Third-Parties?

Click here for a list of which third-party candidates are running.

We are all familiar with the so-called “spoiler” argument against voting third-party: All it takes to win in our electoral system is to have more votes than any other candidate (a plurality), so if there are more than two, a candidate doesn’t need 51% to win. So, if enough people vote Green, for example, than the liberal side is split and the Republicans can end up with the most votes. Or, if enough conservatives vote third-party, the Democrats will end up with the most votes.

Leaving aside, for a moment, the debate between voting one’s conscience or ideals or pragmatically ensuring that the mainstream candidate you like least doesn’t win, in 2016, the math, and the “players” line up very differently than in past years.

In 2000,  a small but vocal movement of liberals/progressives backed Nader because they felt Gore and the Democrats weren’t progressive enough. Nader was the best-known and “biggest” of the third-party candidates. There was no comparable dislike for Bush among those usually allied with the Republicans.

This year, for better or for worse, the usual alliances are falling apart. Billionaire industrialists and lobbyists that leftists – rightly or wrongly – like to cast as supervillians find both Clinton and Trump unpalatable. Some conservatives and Wall Street-ers are supporting Clinton because they are uncomfortable with Trump’s unpredictability, or with his lack of political experience – or with his seemingly-not-very-Republican foreign policy ideas. Some hard-core devotees of Bernie Sanders – who usually like the Greens best out of the third parties – would settle for Trump over Clinton. (Trump has said a few things that far-left voters agree with, mainly about international trade deals.)

Gary Johnson, the Libertarian candidate, has pointed out that he has much in common with Sanders – and many polled Sanders voters have indicated they could vote for Johnson.

And, while there is much dissatisfaction with both major candidates, overall, Trump seems to be the most  unpopular. Prominent conservatives have searched frantically for another conservative to run against him.

Click here for more on “Better For America,” the ongoing movement still claiming it will run an independent conservative candidate.

So the likelihood is that the would-have-been Republicans who “leave” in favor of a third party will out-number the would-have-been Democrats who do so.

As this Salon writer (who seems to support the Greens) puts it, “Who is spoiling for whom?”

Other stories suggest that third party candidates draw from both factions equally. See  “Gary Johnson is an Equal Opportunity Spoiler.” and “One Thing The Polls Agree On: Voters Don’t Like Their Choices.” (Scroll through the top stories to find it.)

Another way of looking at all this might be to say that it’s the “satisfied-with-the-status-quo-or-the-past” voters versus the “change the system” voters. If this is the case, and  Trump is appealing mostly to the change people, then increased attention to the third parties would likely result in a more divided “change” vote, leaving Clinton with the plurality.

Click here and here for more about polls that had third parties in the mix and Clinton coming out ahead.

And while speculation that Trump isn’t trying to win; that he would not serve even if elected; and that he may even have gotten into the race as a “double agent” or “false flag” to damage the GOP and/or help Hillary Clinton win, may sound crazy, much of what has and has not happened with Trump and his campaign is consistent with one or more of those theories.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s